Combating Internal Trafficking at the Manila Port, And Beyond
By Roland Pacis, Visayan Forum Foundation, Inc.
May 28, 2002
Fellow visitors in the port: good afternoon. We thank you for dropping by,
curious about our program. I said "fellow visitors" because we are actually
accidental operators of a unique program by the Philippine Ports Authority. They
have chosen us from the Visayan Forum to operate probably the first of its kind
anti-trafficking strategy in the Asian shipping industry: a halfway house for
victimized women and children stranded, intercepted or who flee from their
recruiters as they pass by the Manila Port.
Come July, we will have been operating here for two years already. Two
fruitful years of exploring what can be done in practical terms to check illegal
recruitment in one of the Asia's busiest ports that is hub to around 5 million
passengers a year. The Problem
Frankly we don't have exact numbers how many are illegally recruited through
this port. The sheer volume of people embarking and disembarking is in itself a
big challenge. But we are constant witnesses to the everyday realities of
trafficking in this gateway.
Victims are very young, mostly female 14- 22 years old from poor regions in
the south. Many are first-timers in Manila, often with only a one-way ticket at
hand. Based on our study, thirteen out of twenty (65%) of children travel to
their destinations without any information about their destination, work, and
employers. Due to absence of protective mechanisms, six out of ten (62%)
revealed that their fare is deducted from their salary and 50% to 70% is added
as a finder's pay by the recruiters. Some 18% of children could not adjust with
the language. Many confided that they met problems related to having not enough
money or none at all during the voyage (31%).
The port therefore is a critical place where illegally recruited victims are
visible and can be helped because once they pass through, they simply vanish
into the city offering a myriad of low-paid and often illegal opportunities to
earn money - from factory jobs and domestic service to bar work and
prostitution.
What the statistics did not show but later on became more evident in the case
profiles of victims temporarily sheltered in the halfway house is that most
parents believe that domestic work is safest so they easily fall prey to false
promises by illegal recruiters and even townmates. One does not need to show
diplomas, birth certificates, and other qualifications to be hired immediately.
It is also realistic to observe that even before searching for work in the
overseas labor market, many young women and children have at least ventured in
other cities inside the country. They eventually seek lucrative opportunities
overseas, after gaining some experience and contact in bigger local cities. Many
of course are recruited directly using false ages and passport names, and are
about to be slipped into some training or processing center. But we increasingly
intercept them with the help of the port police. Project Description
The Visayan Forum Foundation (VF) is a non-governmental organization that
generally works on the issue of domestic workers, mostly hidden, scattered and
invisible to the law. It recently took the cudgels of operating the second
halfway house built by PPA in Davao City just around twenty months after
starting our work here inside this Manila port area. We provide 24-hour safety
and catchment services for trafficking victims including temporary shelter,
help-desk assistance about travel, quick case referrals and telephone hotline
counseling.
- Emergency temporary shelter - We exist to provide a safe
place in the port while waiting for the proper inspection of recruiter's permits
and records. Our end in mind is to work for the victims' eventual reintegration
with their families.
- Informational assistance - We inform passengers about the
issue of trafficking, and assist them about travel, employment and possible
support networks, including contact with their parents. We also help them find
or connect with their relatives in Manila to ensure that they are accessible and
visible.
- Quick referral of cases - Victims have multiple needs, not
just legal action against their recruiters. We therefore refer them to the
specialized NGOs and the social welfare department, which can properly and
speedily repatriate them.
- Regular pier roundings - Our volunteers comb the terminals.
They provide stranded victims with contact numbers so they can call us in times
of needs. Today shipping crews consciously check passengers on board who attempt
to break free from illegal recruiters.
- Telephone hotline counseling - as a form of support
mechanism to those who successfully land in work but are still adjusting to city
life or are exposed to exploitative conditions.
- Training and advocacy - for port community members, to
create a protective network in terms reporting cases, and interception of
suspected traffickers.
VF works to build sustained efforts not only with the Philippine Ports
Authority but also ferry companies, the Coast Guard, Port Police, security
guards and porters. We will not be here forever. Such catchment network is
strengthened by the creative synergy with external collaborators and government
agencies especially in verifying recruiters' work permits, workplace visitation
and taking legal actions or removal operations when needed.
Government Agencies
The Philippine Ports Authority, our joint partner, broke its regular mandate
of port services and expanded into a deeper sense of social responsibility, by
tying up with an NGO to run a half-way house for stranded and trafficked women
and children. The agreement has since extended to 5 years and expanding to other
major ports in the Philippines, including Visayas and Mindanao.
Almost all the agencies under the PPA were mandated to support the program.
Examples of these are the port police and the coastguard, who routinely check
suspected traffickers once the ferry has docked and passengers are about to
disembark. Officers patrol the passenger decks regularly, and invite fetchers of
organized groups before they pack the recruits in transportation bays. Using
this method, they have turned over to the halfway house more than 400 cases
since last year.
The Department of Labor and Employment has always quickly acted on our
request by verifying recruiters' work permits as to the legality of employment
agencies and workplace destinations.
The Department of Social Welfare and Development helps us with our referred
cases, repatriation, and reintegration of intercepted victims and potential
victims of child trafficking. Their regional offices help us locate and
coordinate with the family of the children. Employers/ Shipping
Companies
Major partners from the private employers sector are the shipping companies.
They support our program by offering discounted fare rates to repatriated
children. No less than the ferry managers of a shipping company, the WG&A
ensure safe custody during travel of repatriated children and personally turn
over them to the local social workers who fetch the children in their
destinations. They also help arrange for general orientations of their own
shipping crew on the issue of trafficking. As a result, some of the crew
referred cases to the half-way house and some give information or contact
numbers to children suspected of being victims of trafficking during the voyage.
This kind of help provides useful information to children to avoid abuse and
exploitation in their work destination. Some of the children who accessed our
telephone hotlines are usually reached out by the shipping crew, including their
in-land staff. Workers' Groups
Our partners in the workers groups are mainly composed of stevedores,
porters, cargo handlers and vendors. They have been helping in their own way
stranded passengers in the past when the program was not yet set up. Like other
partners in port communities they continue to refer children who they discovered
to be stranded in the port or children who escaped from their employers. They
even give us food staples for children's consumption in the center.
Expectedly, many recruiters are now forewarned of our catchment efforts hence
changing their facilitation patterns. Still young people who are being
trafficked are surprisingly easy to spot. Often they have been recruited in
their hometowns and go in groups accompanied by a single adult minder who
intends to place them in jobs (confirmed or as yet unfixed) in their
destinations. They are usually under strict orders to stick together and tell
anyone who asks that they are 18 or above. Building efforts by other groups in
the port is therefore crucial.
The cultural acceptance to migration also lends a high degree of
acceptability to recruitment in poor communities, legal or otherwise. Having a
family member work away from home infuses the much-needed cash into the cycle of
debt and bondage, thereby enhancing their family's social status in the
province. RECOMMENDATIONS:
Such effort may possibly be the only one of its kind in the Asian shipping
industry. In closing, may we encourage you to study three concrete
recommendations:
- To replicate the model in other strategic ports around the country and in
Asia as part of integrated national anti-trafficking programs. We can also adopt
and expand the model in other transit points via land and air conduits.
- To connect these efforts into the increasingly recognized plight of domestic
workers who themselves recruit fellow youngsters into invisible work in the
cities.
- To recognize the links between causes and modalities of internal and
external migration. The simple reason is that internal migration helps slingshot
country-to-country migration.
Thank you for visiting us, and we look forward to meeting you again.
|